Tag Archives: early childhood development

Universal Pre-K Will Do More Harm Than Good To African American Children (Unless): A Critical Analysis

All kids need is a little help, a little hope and somebody who believes in them. – Magic Johnson

Universal Pre-K and early childhood development programs are something that is often lauded by the African American community as something that would assist our children and propel them academically in the future. Research shows that early childhood education has lasting long-term effects on children’s socioeconomic outcomes in almost every facet imaginable. However, currently quality early childhood education is largely reserved for more affluent communities. For good reason, the digital publication Prestige in their article ‘Inside the world’s most exclusive and expensive preschools’ noted, “We’re talking chef-made organic meals, sprawling campuses, and field trips to the Galapagos. Admission is highly competitive, often requiring interviews, assessments, and six-figure donations. For the one percent of the one percent, these exclusive early education experiences are less about ABCs and 123s and more about the connections and privilege.” The donations also do not remove one from the responsibility of the tuition which ranges annually from $20,000 to $30,000. These institutions offer art lessons, ballet classes, multiple languages, critical thinking and creativity, development of emotional intelligence, and much more. Things that many adults either get much later in life or never get at all. Having them instilled at three years old almost ensures a parabolic trajectory of success for the rest of life.

The notion that universal pre-k would close that gap is more wishful thinking that pragmatic reality. However, it is argued that something is better than nothing? It is also said that the road to hell is paved with good intentions and that is more likely the case for African American outcomes when it comes to universal pre-k than anything we wishfully hope would come from it. It may serve more as a de facto public day care experience than anything else where working class parents who need to be working and not able to afford day care and therefore caught in a vicious trap of working less and earning less because they cannot afford day care or working more and paying most of the additional income to day care to see a marginal income increase. African Americans in particular though should know by now that nothing is free even when it is said to be so.

We need only examine the outcomes of the public school system as it stands now for African Americans to realize what the outcomes of universal pre-k would produce. More of the same. Maybe worse because anti-indoctrination would essentially be happening immediately. While the argument for more early childhood education is a much needed one for African American children, it is also worth examining who would have the institutional ownership.

African American Schooling Post-Desegregation

Post-desegregation, African American education faced several challenges that have lingering effects today:

  1. Unequal Integration:
    • While desegregation aimed to provide equal opportunities, many African American students remain in segregated schools due to residential patterns and systemic inequities.
    • Even in integrated schools, African American students often experience lower expectations and unequal access to advanced coursework.
  2. Loss of Black Educators and Schools:
    • The closure of historically Black schools during desegregation displaced many Black educators, erasing culturally affirming spaces where African American students thrived.
    • This loss deprived students of role models who understood their cultural and community needs.
  3. Institutional Racism:
    • African American students in integrated schools often faced bias, tracking into lower-level courses, and disproportionate disciplinary actions. These patterns persist today, contributing to unequal educational outcomes.

Current Public School Outcomes for African American Students

The current state of public education reveals persistent inequities that universal pre-K could unintentionally exacerbate for African American children:

  1. Achievement Gaps:
    • African American students consistently score below their white peers on standardized tests, such as the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP).
    • Contributing factors include under-resourced schools, limited access to advanced coursework, and a lack of culturally relevant curricula.
  2. Disciplinary Disparities:
    • African American students are disproportionately disciplined, with preschool-aged African American boys accounting for 43% of suspensions despite being only 19% of enrollment.
    • Early exposure to punitive measures increases the likelihood of negative long-term educational and social outcomes.
  3. Resource Inequities:
    • Schools serving predominantly African American communities are often underfunded, with larger class sizes, fewer qualified teachers, and outdated materials.
    • This lack of resources hinders early literacy, numeracy, and socio-emotional development.
  4. Cultural Disconnects:
    • Many public school curricula and teaching practices fail to reflect or affirm African American cultural identities, leading to disengagement and lower academic performance.

Afrocentric Pre-K in Partnership with HBCUs

To counteract these challenges, Afrocentric pre-K programs, implemented in partnership with Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs), present a transformative solution.

  1. Culturally Relevant Education:
    • Afrocentric curricula incorporate African and African American history, culture, and values, fostering a sense of identity and pride in young learners.
    • Lessons emphasize cooperative learning, creativity, and critical thinking, aligning with African cultural traditions.
  2. HBCU Involvement:
    • HBCUs have long been leaders in producing culturally competent educators and advancing African American scholarship. Partnering with HBCUs allows pre-K programs to draw on their expertise, resources, and community connections.
    • Education students at HBCUs can gain hands-on training through internships and practicum opportunities in Afrocentric pre-K settings.
  3. Teacher Training and Development:
    • HBCUs can offer professional development for pre-K educators, ensuring they are trained in culturally responsive teaching and child development.
    • Programs can also recruit and support Black educators, addressing the underrepresentation of African American teachers in early childhood education.
  4. Community Engagement:
    • Partnerships between Afrocentric pre-K programs and HBCUs can strengthen community ties, involving parents and local organizations in curriculum development and program governance.
    • Family engagement initiatives can provide parents with resources to support learning at home.
  5. Research and Evaluation:
    • HBCUs can lead research to assess the impact of Afrocentric pre-K programs on academic and social outcomes, ensuring continuous improvement.
    • Findings can inform policies to expand successful models nationally.

Key Features of Afrocentric Pre-K in Partnership with HBCUs

  1. Curriculum Highlights:
    • Focus on African diasporic history and cultural pride.
    • Integration of science, technology, engineering, arts, and mathematics (STEAM) with a culturally relevant lens.
    • Emphasis on social-emotional learning and conflict resolution rooted in community values.
  2. Accessible Locations:
    • Programs hosted on or near HBCU campuses to leverage facilities, staff, and community networks.
  3. Empowerment-Focused Funding:
    • Public and private funding to ensure accessibility for all African American families. This could be led by HBCU alumni creating endowments for these partnerships.
  4. Mentorship Opportunities:
    • Pairing pre-K students and their families with mentors from HBCU student bodies, fostering intergenerational learning and support.
  5. Holistic Approach:
    • Nutrition, healthcare, and family support services integrated into the program to address broader disparities impacting African American children.

Recommendations for Implementation

  1. Policy Advocacy:
    • Advocate for federal and state funding to establish Afrocentric pre-K programs in partnership with HBCUs.
    • Push for accountability measures to ensure equitable distribution of resources.
  2. Pilot Programs:
    • Launch pilot Afrocentric pre-K programs at selected HBCUs to refine the model and gather evidence of effectiveness.
  3. Community Collaboration:
    • Partner with African American community organizations, churches, and local businesses to support and sustain programs.
  4. Long-Term Expansion:
    • Use data from pilot programs to scale Afrocentric pre-K nationally, prioritizing areas with high African American populations and educational inequities.

Universal pre-K, if not carefully implemented and there is little reason to believe it would be, risks perpetuating systemic inequities faced by African American children. Afrocentric pre-K programs owned by the communities or even under a unified African American organization, developed in collaboration with HBCUs, offer a culturally affirming, high-quality alternative that addresses historical and contemporary challenges. By grounding education in cultural pride, community engagement, and academic rigor, these programs can equip African American children with the foundation they need to thrive academically and socially. This provides an opportunity for the African American education pipeline to be extended and strengthened from early childhood education through higher education in institutions of our own.

Our decisions at their core must revolve around the strengthening of the African American institutional ecosystem and educational pipeline. We are training the future leadership of our institutions and the work begins immediately.

5 Ways Black Men Can Invest In Black Boys

“It is easier to build strong children than to repair broken men.” – Frederick Douglas

The statistics and data around Black boys/men is and has been alarming for decades. As African Americans in the post-Civil Rights era began to abandon our own institutions arguably nobody has suffered as a result more than Black boys. In almost every category of substance Black boys/men trail and trail significantly against the overall society and within our own community. The consequences of this is seen in the struggles of our communities, institutions, and families. Where are the Black men is a question that is asked so often in spaces that in many ways it has become redundant. Unfortunately, the answer is they were lost as Black boys never to be seen from again in many ways. To become substantive members of our community, families, and institutions requires education, training, mentorship, and so much more. The reality on the ground is that there is very little in the way of organizations or resources that provides enough of that. While Black women have taken upon themselves to create, support, and fund initiatives that support the development and growth of Black girls, Black men have not done the same for Black boys. Conversations between Black men about how they can help Black boys tends to seemingly 99 percent revolve around sports as an answer. Black boys and sports has become a catch all for all things that ail Black boys and yet the outcomes suggest that is a failed investment. The question now is what going forward can Black men do to holistically develop and improve the outcomes of Black boys. Take responsibility and accountability for them. The time for deflecting blame is a broken record in many instances and while there are external forces at work constantly against African American men and our boys, we would be remiss not to as men deal with the protection and providing for them within our control.

  1. Pre-K-5 Investment Is Imperative. African American boys get lost and they get lost early. The majority of any investment made into African American boys needs to be made in early childhood development. This is where boys develop cultural identity, mental health fundamentals, educational confidence, and more. Any conversations that we have about Black boys needs to be heavily weighted on reaching them as early as possible and as often as possible. The foundation of anything being built will always be the most important part of that structure.
  2. Donating To African American Organizations That Specifically Support Black Boys. The easiest thing any of us can do is make sure the organizations that are trying to help our boys have the resources they need to not only fulfill their mission, but to excel at their mission and to exceed their missions expectations. For African American organizations who receive less than 2 percent of all national funding into NPOs, this is a mountainous hurdle. African American men can simply make sure they are active donors if they can afford to be and anything is better than nothing as the old saying goes. African American men can do this individually, but the stronger pathway would be as a collective. Two friends or twenty friends of African American men giving together is powerful for accountability towards giving, conversations about giving, strategic pathways to giving, and of course more capital towards giving.
  3. Create More Organizations That Support Black Boys. Simply put, there just are not many African American organizations that are targeted towards developing Black boys. Arguably, that is because African American men have not created them. This is where inevitably Black boys get funneled into sports and nothing else. Largely because that is what is available. Organizations that solely focus on and encourage Black boys to develop themselves educationally, mentally, artistically, and more are largely absent and in need of existence on the nonprofit landscape. African American men have to take the responsibility of identifying, cultivating, and developing areas where Black boys need development and creating organizations around them. To be clear, we are not talking about organizations where it is boys of color or side initiatives, but actual organizations being created where Black boys are the focus, period.
  4. Subsidizing Black Boys Supplemental Education. Black boys throughout K-12 do not get nearly enough supplemental education. The basic nature of supplemental education is everything that happens outside of a child’s classroom that makes them stronger in the classroom at its essence. Providing Black boys and their families assistance with tutoring costs, trips to museums, art galleries, academic camps, therapy, etc.
  5. Give Your TIME and Be PRESENT. This is free. For whatever reason, African American men are plain and simply absent in activities for Black boys beyond sports. From Boy Scouts, tutors, mentors, and civic engagement in general, African American men are just missing for reasons that are frustratingly hard to understand.

What are we up against? Here are just a few reasons African American men need to be at the forefront of the needs of African American boys.

  • The 2019 National Assessment of Education Progress data also highlighted that only 6% of 12th-grade Black males were reading at the proficient level and only 1% were reading at the advanced level.
  • In 2021, 76% of Black boys finished high school compared to 93% of Asian boys.
  • According to the National Center for Education Statistics, only 36% of Black male students completed a bachelor’s degree within six years (52% of Latino male students completed theirs within the same time. White males graduated at a rate of 63% in six years.)
  • U.S. Census reports African American boys 17 and under comprise over 40% of the African American males in poverty.
  • Of the 12.3 million African American men over the age of 25, almost 50% have only a high school diploma or less according to the U.S. Census.

There is a war going on against African American boys and African American men are leaving them to fight for themselves. Our boys are more than their physicality. They are thinkers, they are astronauts, teachers, gardeners, and so much more, but like a flower they too must be nourished and care for by us. African American men can not leave African American boys to experience the gauntlet of life too many of us have already lived.